Goce Naumov

Ss. Cyril and Methodius University (University of Skopje, Macedonia)
<gocenaumov@gmail.com>


Download full-text article


Dig It: The Journal of the Flinders Archaeological Society
Volume 2, Issue 1, June 2014

Print: ISSN 1440-2475
Online: ISSN 2203-1898


Abstract

Neolithic figurines are often subject of keen discussions and debates between two main theoretical standpoints. The one side tends towards deification of the anthropomorphic figurines, whilst the other determines these artefacts as mediators in social relation among individuals and communities. Thus, the first group of researchers idolises the figurines as fertility symbols, whereas the others considerably profane their social function. This paper aims to explore these breaking points and from there on to develop multi-relational interpretations towards the character of some Neolithic figurines. In this context figurines found in the settlements from the Republic of Macedonia will be used for further observations. Particular cases associated with medieval and contemporary visual culture, as well as recent gender ritual issues will be proposed for thorough understanding of the body representations.


References

Bailey, D. 1994 The representation of gender: Homology or propaganda. Journal of European Archaeology 2(2):215–227.

Bailey, D. 2005 Prehistoric Figurines: Representation and corporeality in the Neolithic. London: Routledge.

Bemberdjer, D. 2003 Mit o matrijarhatu: zasto u primitivnomdrustvuvladajumuskarci? [The myth of matriarchate: Why men rule primitive societies].In Z. Papic and L. Sklevick (eds), Antropologijazene, pp. 243–267 Beograd: Knizara Krug.

Biehl, P.F. 1996 Symbolic communication systems: Symbols of the Neolithic and Chalcolithic from south-eastern Europe. Journal of European Archaeology 4:153–176.

Biehl, P.F. 1997 Overcoming the ‘Mother-Goddess Movement’: A new approach to the study of human representations. Proceedings of the Latvian Academy of Science 4–5:59–67.

Biehl, P.F. 1999 Analogy and context: Re-construction of the missing Link. Urgeschichtliche Materialhefte 14:171–184.

Bilbija, M. 1986 Cerje, neolitsko naselje [Cerje-Neolithic settlement].Arheološki Pregled 26: 35–36.

Bolger, D. 2003 Gender in Ancient Cyprus: Narratives of social change on a Mediterranean island. Walnut Creek: Altamira Press.

Chapman, J. 2000 Fragmentation in archaeology: People, places and broken objects in the prehistory of south-eastern Europe. London: Routledge.

Chausidis, N. 1995 Predistorija [Prehistory]. In N. Chausidis (ed.), Makedonija kulturno nasledstvo, pp. 17–45. Skopje: Misla.

Chausidis, N., 2007 Ženata kako personifikacija na prostorot za živeenje (od neolitot do sovremeniot folklor)[woman as the personification for living space]. In J. Lužina (ed.),Makedonskiot teatar vo kontekst na Balkanskata teatarska sfera, pp.45–101. Skopje: Fakultet za dramski umetnosti.

Chausidis, N. 2008 Otvoritena neolitskitežrtvenici od tipot ‘Majka-Kukja’ [the openings on Neolithic altars ‘Mother-House’]. Macedoniae Acta Archaeologica 18:75–92.

Chausidis, N. 2010 Neolithic ceramic figurines in the shape of a woman –housefrom the Republic of Macedonia. In D. Gheorghiu and A. Cyphers (eds), Anthropomorphic and Zoomorphic miniature figures in Eurasia, Africa and Meso-America: morphology, materiality, technology, function and context, pp. 25–35. Oxford: Archaeopress.

Chausidis, N.,and G. Nikolov 2006 Crepna i vršnik. Mitološko – semiotićka analiza. Studia Mythologica Slavica 9: 97–160.

Conkey, M., and R. Tringham 1995 Archaeology and the Goddess: Exploring the contours of feminist archaeology. In D. Stanton and J. Stewart (eds), Feminism in the Academy, pp. 199–247. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

Djurić, V. 1974 Vizantijske freske u Jugoslaviji [Byzantine frescoes in Yugoslavia]. Beograd: Izdavački zavod Jugoslavija.

Fidanoski, L. 2011 ArheološkiiskopuvanjananeolitskatanaselbaCerje-Govrlevovo 2004 godina [excavations on Neolithic settlement Cerje-Govrlevo 2004]. Macedonia Acta Archaeologica20: 53–76.

Fidanoski, L. 2012 Cerje-Govrlevo and MilošBilbija. Skopje: Museum of Skopje.

Fidanoski, L., and A. Tomaž 2010 Pod žitnitepolinja: istražuvanjana “Cerje”-Govrlevo [under the fields of wheat: research at Cerje-Govrlevo]. Makedonskonasledstvo 36-37:53–69

Fleming, A. 1969 The myth of the Mother-Goddess. World Archaeology 1:247–261.

Galović, R.1964 Neue Funde der Starcevo-Kultur in Mittelserbien und Makedonien.Berlin: Walter De Gruyter.

Garašanin, M. 1979 Centralno-balkanska zona [Central Balkan zone]. In A. Benac (ed.),Praistorija jugoslavenskih zemaljaII: neolit, pp. 79–212. Sarajevo: Academy of Science and Art of Bosnia and Hercegovina.

Garašanin, M., and M. Bilbija 1988 Kuća 1 vo Zelenikovo [House1 in Zelenikovo].Macedonia Acta Archaeologica9: 31–41.

Garašanin, M., and D. Garašanin 1961 Neolitska naselba “Vršnik” kaj selo Tarinci [Neolithic settlement Vrshnik at Tarinci].Zbornik na štipskiot naroden muzej 2:7–40.

Garašanin, M., and G. Spasovska 1976 Novi iskopuvanja vo Zelenikovo kaj Skopje [New excavations in Zelenikovo at Skopje]. Macedoniae Acta Archaeologica 2:85–115.

Garašanin, M., V. Sanev, D. Simoska and B. Kitanoski 1976 Predistoriski kulturi vo Makedonija [Prehistoric cultures in Macedonia]. Štip: Naroden muzej Štip.

Gaydarska, B., J. Chapman and I. Angelova 2007 On the tell and off the tell: The fired clay figurines from omurtag. In V. Spinei, C.-M. Lazarovici and D. Monah (eds), Scripta Praehistorica: Miscellanea in honorem nonagenarii magistri Mircea Petrescu-Dîmboviţa oblata, pp.341–385. Iasi: Trinitas.

Georgiev, Z., and M. Bilbija 1984 Neolitska naselba kaj Govrlevo [Neolithic settlement at Govrelvo]. Kulturno Nasledstvo 9:39–48.

Georgudi, S. 2011Sozdavanjetomitzamatrijarhatot [the matriarchate myth creation]. In P. Shmit Pantel (ed.), Istorijanazenitenazapadot: Od antickibozici do hristijanskisvetici. Skopje: Evro Balkan Press.

Gheorghiu, D. 2001 The cult of ancestors in the East European Chalcolithic. A holographic approach.In P. Biehl, F. Bertemes and H. Meller (eds),The Archaeology of Cult and Religion, pp.73–88. Budapest: Archaeolingua.

Gimbutas, M. 1976a Figurines. In M. Gimbutas (ed.), Anza, Neolithic Macedonia: As reflected by excavation at Anza, Southeast Yugoslavia, pp.198–241. Los Angeles: The Regents of the University of California.

Gimbutas, M. 1976b Neolithic Macedonia: As Reflected by Excavation at Anza, Southeast Yugoslavia. Los Angeles: The Regents of the University of California.

Gimbutas, M. 1982 The Goddesses and Gods of Old Europe. London: Thames and Hudson.

Gimbutas, M. 1989 The Language of the Goddess. London: Thames and Hudson.

Golan, A. 2003 Prehistoric Religion. Jerusalem: Golan.

Grabar, A. 1982 Christian Iconography: A Study of its Origins, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Grbić, M. 1954 Arheološki naogjališta vo Makedonija [Archaeological sites in Macedonia]. Glasnik na makedonskoto konzervatorskoto društvo 9:100–142.

Grbić, M., P. Mačkić, Š.Nadj, D. Simoska and B.  Stalio 1960 Porodin: kasno-neolitsko naselje na Tumbi kod Bitolja [Porodin-Late Neolithic Settlemnt near Bitola]. Bitolj: Narodni muzej Bitolj i Arheolośki institut.

Grozdanov, C., and L. Haderman Misguich 1992 Kurbinovo. Skopje: Makedonska kniga.

Haaland, G., and R. Haaland 1995Whospeaks the Goddesses’ Language? Imagination and method in archaeological research.Norwegian Archaeological Review 28:105–121.

Hamilton, N., J. Marcus, D. Bailey, G. Haaland, R. Haaland and P. Ucko 1996 Can we interpret the figurines? Cambridge Archaeological Journal 6(2):281–307.

Handsman, R.G. 1991Whose art was found at Lepenski Vir? Gender relations and power in archaeology.In J. Gero and M. Conkey (eds), Engendering Archaeology: Women and Prehistory, pp. 329–365. Oxford: Blackwell.

Hansen, S. 2007Bilder vom Menschen der Steinzeit: Untersuchungen zur Anthropomorphen Plastik der Jungsteinzeit und Kupfzeit in Südosteuropa I und II. Mainz: Philipp von Zabern.

Hardie, R. 2007 Gender tensions in figurines in SE Europe. In C. Malone and D. Barrowclough (eds), Cult in Context, pp.82–89. Oxford: Oxbow Books.

Hollimon, S.E. 1997 The Third Gender in Native California: Two-Spirit undertakers among the Chumash and their neighbors. In C. Claassen and R. Joyce (eds), Women in Prehistory: North America and Mesoamerica, pp. 173–188. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

James, P.O. 1959. The Cult of the Mother Goddess: An Archaeological and Documentary Study. London: Thames and Hudson.

Joyce, R.A. 1993Embodying Personhood in Prehispanic Costa Rica. Wellesley: Davis Museum and Cultural Center.

Joyce, R.A. 2000Gender and Power in Prehispanic Mesoamerica. Austin: University of Texas Press.

Joyce, R.A. 2003 Makingsomething of herself: Embodiment of life and death at Playa De Los Muertos, Honduras. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 13:246–261.

Joyce, R.A. 2005 Archaeology of the body. Annual Review of Anthropology 34:139–158.

Karpuzova, K. 2007 NeolitskaantropomorfnaplastikanateritorijatanaRepublikaMakedonija [Neolithic Anthropomorphic Figurines in Macedonia]. Unpublished MA thesis, Institute for History of Art and Archaeology, University of Skopje, Skopje.

Knapp, B., and L. Meskell 1997 Bodies of evidence on prehistoric Cyprus. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 7(2):183–204.

Kolištrkoska Nasteva, I. 2005 Praistoriskite dami od Makedonija [Prehistoric Ladies in Macedonia]. Skopje: Muzej na Makedonija.

Korošec, J. 1954 Nekolikoprimerapreistoriskeplastikeiz Makedonije [Several Examples with Prehistoric Figurines from Macedonia].Glasnikna Muzejsko-konzervatorskotodrustvona NR Makedonija 8: 89–98.

Korošec, P.,and L. Korošec 1973Predistoriska naselba Barutnica [Prehistoric Settlement Barutnica]. Prilep: Arheološko društvo na Makedonija.

Krstevska, M. 2005 Kolekcijata na šaralki za obredni lebovi vo Muzejot na Makedonija [Collection of Pintaderas in the Museum of Macedonia]. Zbornik na Muzejot na Makedonija – Etnologija 3: 15–29.

Lesure, R.G. 2002 The Goddess diffracted: Thinking about the figurines of early villages. Current Anthropology 43(4):587–610.

Lesure, R.G. 2011 Interpreting Ancient Figurines: Context, Comparison and Prehistoric Art. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Malešević, M. 1995 Odnos svekrve i snahe u svadbenom ritualu [The Relationship Between Mother in law and Daughter in law in Wedding Ritual]. Etno-kulturološki zbornik za proućavanje kulture istoćne Srbije i susednih oblasti1:177–184.

Marcus. J. 1996The importance of context in interpreting figurines. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 6:285–291.

McDermott, L. 1996 Self-representation in Upper Paleolithic Female figurines. Current Anthropology 37(2):227–275.

Mellaart, Ј. 1967 Çatal Hüyük: A Neolithic Town in Anatolia. London: Thames and Hudson.

Meskell, L. 1995 Godessess, Gimbutas and ‘New Age’ archaeology. Antiquity 69:74–86.

Meskell, L. 1998 Twin Peaks: The Archaeologies of Çatalhöyük. In C. Morris and L. Goodison (eds), Ancient Goddesses: The Myths and the Evidence, pp.46–62. London: British Museum Press.

Meskell, L. 2001 Archaeologies of identity. In I. Hodder (ed.),Archaeological Theory Today, pp.187–213. Cambridge: Polity.

Miljković-Pepek, P. 1971 Materijalizaistorijatanasrednovekovnotoslikarstvovo

Makedonija III: Freskitevonaosot I narteksotnacrkvataSv. Sofija vo Ohrid) [History of Medieval Paintings in Macedonia]. Kulturno nasledstvo3:311–321.

Morss, N. 1954 Clay figurines of American Southwest. Cambridge: Peabody Museum.

Nakamura, C., and L. Meskell 2009 Articulate bodies: Forms and figures at Çatalhöyük. Journal of Archaeological method and Theory 16: 205–230.

Nanoglou, S. 2006 Regional perspectives on the Neolithic anthropomorphic imagery of Northern Greece. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 19(2):155–176.

Naumov, G. 2006 Sadot, pećkata I kukjatavosimbolićkarelacija so matkata I ženata (neolitskipredloški I etnografskiimplikacii) [The vessel, oven and house in symbolic relationship with the womb and woman].Studia Mythologica Slavica 9: 59–95.

Naumov, G. 2008a The vessel as a human body: Neolithic anthropomorphic vessels and their reflection in later periods. In I. Berg (ed.), Breaking the Mould: challenging the past through pottery. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.

Naumov, G. 2008b Imprints of the Neolithic mind: Clay seals from the Neolithic Macedonia.DocumentaPraehistorica 35:185–204.

Naumov, G. 2009a Patterns and Corporeality: Neolithic visual culture from Republic of Macedonia. Oxford: Archaeopress.

Naumov, G. 2009b Neolithic visual culture and rituals. In G. Naumov, L. Fidanoski, I. Tolevski and A. Ivkovska(eds), Neolithic Communities in the Republic of Macedonia, pp.87–135. Skopje: Dante.

Naumov, G. 2009c The process of Neolithization. In G. Naumov, L. Fidanoski, I. Tolevski and A. Ivkovska(eds), Neolithic Communities in the Republic of Macedonia, pp.17–27. Skopje: Dante.

Naumov, G. 2010a Neolithic anthropocentrism: imagery principles and symbolic manifestation of corporeality in the Balkans. DocumentaPraehistorica 37: 227–238.

Naumov, G. 2010b Symmetry analysis of Neolithic painted pottery from Republic of Macedonia. In T. Biro-Katalin(ed.), Data Management and Mathematical Methods in Archaeology, pp. 255–274. Roma: Dipartimento Patrimonio Culturale.

Naumov, G. 2011. Visual and Conceptual Dynamism of the Neolithic Altars in the Republic of Macedonia. In V. Nikolov, K. Bacvarov and H. Popov (eds), Interdisziplinäre Forschungen der Kulturerbe auf dem Balkan, pp.89–129. Sofia: Nice.

Naumov, G. 2013 Embodied houses: social and symbolic agency of Neolithic architecture in the Republic of Macedonia. In D. Hoffman and J. Smyth (eds), Tracking the Neolithic house in Europe: sedentism, architecture and practice, pp. 65–94. New York: Springer.

Naumov, G. 2014 Neolithic Privileges: the selection within burials and corporeality in the Balkans. European Journal of Archaeology 17(2):184–207.

Naumov, G. in press Together we stand – divided we fall: Fragmentation of Neolithic figurines in Republic of Macedonia. In S. Kohring and R. Farbstein (eds),Representation, Image and the Materiality of Technology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Naumov, G., and N. Chausidis 2011 Neolitskite antropomorfnipredmetivo RepublikaMakedonija [Neolithic Anthropomorphic Objects in Macedonia]. Skopje: Magor.

Nemeskéri, J., and L. Lengyel 1976 Neolithic skeletal finds. In M. Gimbutas (ed.),Neolithic Macedonia: As Reflected by Excavation at Anza, Southeast Yugoslavia, pp.375–410. Los Angeles: The Regents of the University of California.

Neumann, E. 1963 The Great Mother: Analysis of an Archetype. New York: Bollingen Foundation.

Petreska, V. 2001 Odnosot svekrva’snaa vo makedonskiot svadben obred (memorija i perspektivi)[The relationship between mother in law and daughter in law in Macedonian wedding ritual]. Makedonski folklor 58–59:167–186.

Petreska, V. 2002 Svadbata kako obred na premin kaj Makedoncite od brsjaćkata etnografska celina [The Wedding as Rite of Passage among Macedonians]. Skopje: Institut za folklor “Marko Cepenkov”.

Petrović, S. 1996 Magijsko – mitološki smisao slavskog hleba „baba“ u Istočnoj Srbiji [Magical and Mythical Essence of the Ritual Bread ’Grandmother’]. Glasnik etnografskog instituta SANU 95:19–36.

Radojčić, S. 1964 Prilozizaistorijunajstarijegohridskogslikarstva [Contribution in the Earliest OhridPaintings]. Zbornikradova Vizantološkoginstitute 8(2):355–381.

Renaud, E.B. 1929 Prehistoric female figurines from America and Old World.Scientific Monthly 28(6):507–512.

Robb, J. 2007. The Early Mediterranean Village: Agency, Material Culture and Social Change in Neolithic Italy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Robb, J. 2008 Tradition and agency: human body representations in later prehistoric Europe. World Archaeology 40(3):332–353.

Sanev, V. 1975 Neolitskata naselba Rug Bair kaj c. Gorobinci [Neolithic Settlement at Gorobinci]. Zbornik na štipskiot naroden muzej 4–5:203–245.

Sanev, V. 1988 Neolitskoto svetilište od “Tumba” vo Madjari [Neolithic Sanctuary at Tumba Madjari].Мacedoniae Аcta Аrchaeologica9:9–30.

Sanev, V. 2006 Anthropomorphic cult plastic of Anzabegovo-Vršnikcultural group of the Republic of Macedonia.In N. Tasić and C. Grozdanov(eds), Homage to MilutinGaraśanin, pp. 171 191. Belgrade: SASA.

Sanev, V. (ed.) 2009 Anzabegovo: naselbaodraniotisredniot neolit vo Makedonija [Amzabegovo-Early and Middle Neolithic Settlement in Macedonia]. Štip: Nacional naustanovazazaštitanaspomenicitena kulturata I muzej.

Simoska D., and V. Sanev 1976 Praistorija vo Centralna Pelagonija [Prehistory of Central Pelagonia]. Bitola: Museum of Bitola.

Skeates, R. 1994 Ritual, context, and gender in Neolithic south-eastern Italy. Journal of European Archaeology 2(2):199–214.

Soffer, O., J. Adovasio and D. Hyland 2000 The ‘Venus’ figurines: textiles, basketry, gender and status in the Upper Paleolithic. Current Anthropology 41(4):511–537.

Srejović, D. 1968NeolitskaplastikaCentralnogBalkana [Neolithic figurines in the Central Balkan]. In L. Trifunović (ed.),NeolitCentralnogBalkana, pp. 177–270. Beograd: Narodnimuzej.

Talalay, L. 1993 Deities, dolls and devices, Neolithic figurines form Franchthi Cave.In T.W. Jacobsen (ed.), Excavation in Franchthi Cave, Greece, Volume 9. Indianapolis: Indiana University Press.

Talalay, L. 1994 A Feminist boomerang: The Great Goddess of Greek prehistory. Gender and History 6(2):165–183.

Talalay, L. 2004 Heady business: Skulls, heads and decapitation in Neolithic Anatolia and Greece. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 17(2):139–163.

Temelkoski, D., and A. Mitkoski 2001 Neolitski antropomorfni statuetki vo predistoriskata zbirka na Zavod i muzej Prilep [Neolithic Anthropomorphic Figurines in Prilep]. Makedonsko nasledstvo 17: 53–69.

Tringham, R., and M. Conkey 1998 Rethinking figurines: a critical analysis of archaeology, feminism and popular culture. In L. Goodison and C. Morris (eds), Ancient Goddesses: The Myths and the Evidence, pp.22–45. London: British Museum Press.

Ucko, P. 1962 The interpretation of prehistoric anthropomorphic figurines. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 92:38–54.

Ucko, P. 1968 Anthropomorphic Figurines of Predynastic Egypt and Neolithic Crete, with Comparative Material from the Prehistoric Near East and Mainland Greece. London: Andrew Szmilda.

Ucko, P. 1996 Mother, are you there? Cambridge Archaeological Journal 6(2):300–304.

Voigt, M.M. 2000 ÇatalHöyük in context: Ritual at Early Neolithic sites in Central and Eastern Turkey. In I. Kuijt (ed.), Life in Neolithic Farming Communities: Social Organization, Identity and Differentiation, pp.253–293. New York: Plenum.

Vražinovski, T. 1999 Narodna tradicija, religija i kultura [Folk Tradition, Religion and Culture]. Skopje: Matica Makedonska.

Vražinovski, T. 2000 Rećnik na narodnata mitologija na makedoncite [The Dictionary of FolkMythology of Macedoninans].Skopje: Istitut za staroslovenska kultura & Matica makedonska.

White, R. 2006 The women of Brassempouy: A century of research and interpretation. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 13(4):251–304.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *